-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%

12 Influencer-Touted ETFs That Have Fallen Out of Favor. Don't Discount the Risks of Acting on Social Media Investing Advice

Barchart·11/19/2026 15:37:11
Listen to the news

There’s a favorite line of mine from the movie A League of Their Own, where the ballpark public address announcer (who happens to be the actor who played Squiggy in the classic television series Laverne & Shirley) sees a crazy play on the field. 

I have seen enough to know I have seen too much.

That’s also my reaction to the overwhelming amount of noise in my social media inbox. Particularly when I venture into the entertaining but addictive, and dare I say, toxic world of Instagram. That platform contains its own content from masses of financial advice “creators,” many of whom simply repost their content from TikTok.

I bring this up not to wax poetic about social media. We all choose to use it as we wish, believe what we want to believe, and follow what we want to follow. The algorithms go where they think they want us to go.

In part, my own social feed has developed a habit of pointing me to hundreds of folks my kids' ages (20s and early 30s) who use a video camera, clever editing, and quick talking as a substitute for credentials and experience.

It wasn’t a problem for the receiving audience, especially since this type of content serves a very valid purpose. Namely, to introduce newer investors to the basics of investing (security selection and portfolio construction).

To be clear, I am a big proponent of investor education. But unless/until this online advice is regulated carefully, there’s nothing any of us can do about the seemingly obvious issue: no one talks about the risk of major loss. 

And I think I know why — here are three reasons.

  1. The audience does not have much to lose in dollar terms, as they are often just starting out as investors. To me, that is a poor excuse for having so much unsupervised investment advice described as “information and content,” despite the obligatory disclaimer that “it is not financial advice.” With all the temptations around us, right on our phones, there’s a good chance this will end poorly for many. It's no different from sports betting and prediction markets. While we all want to be entertained, investing is not entertainment, or at least it should not be.
  2. The stock market at the headline (SPY) level has done so well for so long that it is attracting the masses and creating a free-for-all. It is also the new way to monetize, well, just about anything.
  3. The hype machine is so strong, and a whole generation of investors has become smitten with stock investing because they’ve only seen it during the good times.

Favorite ETFs touted by influencers need a dislike button

I spent some time consuming content on Instagram, and it occurred to me that many financial influencers were talking about the same “book.” So I boiled it down to a dozen ETFs I saw most often and added them to a watchlist called “Influencer Faves.” (Feel free to suggest others that you’ve seen.)

image.png
www.barchart.com

That’s the list, the ones the “long-term” investors are being “sold” without it actually being transacted. But it sure gets the likes and shares!

And since I can’t predict the future, the point I’m making is that the 100-day column shows some bloom is off this rose. And as in past cycles, few people care, other than the ones directly impacted. If you own a portfolio filled with cloud computing stocks, you understand what I mean —  you’re hurting.

But so far, most influencer favorites fail to highlight the very real risk that they could invest now and go a decade or more without making money. I’m not saying that will happen, but the masses do not even realize it CAN happen.

No matter what your age or level of investing experience, the other side of the story needs to be told.

image.png
Chart courtesy of Rob Isbitts.

The above chart has a message. It says that all of those ETFs have at least a 34% decline on their resume. For the Invesco QQQ Trust ETF (QQQ) and the State Street Technology Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLK) — two very popular holdings among this crowd — their past lives include a decline of 82%. That takes a 5-to-1 gain/recovery just to get back to where you started.

When an abnormal period of high returns occurs, time suddenly becomes a factor — here’s what I mean.

image.png
Chart courtesy of Rob Isbitts.

​The performance in the 1990s was a lot like the current decade. Then, in 2000, $50,000 invested in SPY fell to under $30,000. 

No problem, it always comes back, right?

And it sure did. But not until the end of 2011! Turning $50k into $53k over 12 years. 

While a simple 5% return — the kind of return investors can get just for clicking the buy button on a 10-year U.S. Treasury bond — grew to more than $91,000.

It helps not to get fixated. Not on the stock market, not on the “easy way” often pitched by influencers. They are not fiduciaries, and most can't express the other side of investing. The part where you learn expensive lessons.

If that happens to people now, with all of the information out there, but none of the filters that existed before social media, don’t blame the influencers. They are simply playing the monetization game. Blame yourself.

Or better yet, learn more about the range of possible outcomes that exist in the stock market. That will allow you to go into your investment journey with eyes wide open.

Rob Isbitts created the ROAR Score, based on his 40+ years of technical analysis experience. ROAR helps DIY investors manage risk and create their own portfolios. For Rob's written research, check out ETFYourself.com.


On the date of publication, Rob Isbitts did not directly have a position in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.