Metals and mining ETFs can look interchangeable at first glance. Tick up a ticker like GDX, GDXJ or GNR and the names all sound close enough that it is easy to assume you are getting the same exposure. Pick one without checking what is actually inside and you can end up with a very different bet than you intended.
That difference matters more right now because the Army has signed a long term lease for REalloys to build a rare earth processing plant on a US base. New sourcing rules already limit defense contractors from using magnets tied to processing in China, Russia, North Korea or Iran, so a domestic plant changes how miners and processors can sell dysprosium, terbium and other rare earths into future military contracts.
GDX, GDXJ and GNR all touch metals and mining to very different degrees, which gives you three distinct ways to aim at that rare earth story. One fund focuses on gold miners. Another adds smaller producers and diversified metals. A third mixes miners with large integrated energy groups. Understanding those splits is what helps you decide which exposure matches the bet you actually want to make.
| Fund | Fee | Assets | 5-year annualised return after fees | Top holding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VanEck Gold Miners ETF (GDX) | 0.51% | US$25.01 billion | 21.3% | Newmont 11.6% |
| VanEck Junior Gold Miners ETF (GDXJ) | 0.52% | US$7.29 billion | 18.7% | Alamos Gold 6.55% |
| State Street SPDR S&P Global Natural Resources ETF (GNR) | 0.4% | US$5.28 billion | 9.6% | Shell 5.18% |
Where could strong businesses be hiding behind a cheap share price? Explore 37 high quality undervalued stocks combining solid balance sheets and cash flows with potential value beyond the headline.
Holdings: 66 | In metals and mining: 99.5% of the fund
This ETF leans heavily into gold miners such as Newmont and Agnico Eagle Mines, which together make up 23.1% of the fund, with Barrick Mining adding more large scale production muscle. Almost all holdings sit in metals and mining, and 91.6% of the portfolio is in gold companies, so any shift in defense demand for critical materials could help indirectly by supporting broader mining investment and processing know how. The fund tracks the NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index, providing a rule based basket instead of picking individual miners tied to the Pentagon rare earth project.
Because so much of the portfolio depends on gold rather than dedicated rare earth producers, you are still relying on how large miners allocate capital across different deposits and processing projects. That concentration in a single industry can help keep the theme clear, but it leaves you exposed to gold price swings and project execution that do not move in lockstep with rare earth policy.
Not every stock inside GDX is priced the same way. Find out how many of GDX's holdings look undervalued.
Holdings: 160 | In metals and mining: 98.9% of the fund
Alamos Gold is the biggest position in GDXJ and runs producing gold mines rather than early stage prospects, with Equinox Gold and Coeur Mining adding more operating projects and some silver exposure. Together Alamos Gold and Equinox Gold make up 12.8% of this ETF, which gives you more spread than the heavier top weight in GDX and more emphasis on smaller producers. Those kinds of businesses can see indirect benefits from a new US rare earth processing plant because policy support for domestic supply chains can encourage broader mining infrastructure and processing capacity that gold focused operators also use.
Investors still get a portfolio that is about 81.3% in gold and just 5.2% in diversified metals and mining, so the rare earth angle is secondary rather than central. That leaves you depending on how junior gold and silver producers manage exploration risk, project timelines and capital needs, which can be more volatile than the larger companies in GDX despite the partial 32% overlap between the two funds.
Compare how far GDXJ is ahead of or behind the market across six periods
Holdings: 116 | In metals and mining: 30.1% of the fund
This ETF leans on a broad mix of resources companies rather than a tight cluster of metals stocks. Shell at 5.18% and ExxonMobil at 5.04% illustrate how much of GNR is tied to large integrated oil and gas, while BHP Group at 4.59% represents the diversified mining side that could connect most directly to rare earth extraction and processing. Only 30.1% of the fund is in metals and mining, with the rest spread across areas such as energy, fertilizers and agricultural products, so the rare earth policy story is only one of several drivers.
Investors are relying on the S&P Global Natural Resources Index to combine that energy-heavy tilt with exposure to miners such as BHP Group, plus holdings in areas such as agricultural chemicals and steel that sit away from the Pentagon project. The rare earth angle is more diluted than in GDX or GDXJ because Shell and ExxonMobil together account for 10.2% of the fund, while BHP on its own represents a smaller portion of the portfolio.
See what you'd actually own if you bought GNR, from its 116 positions to how much sits in the top 10.
If you want the rare earth story to run mainly through big miners that already fund large projects, GDX and GDXJ line up closest. GDX is almost entirely metals and mining with a heavy tilt to gold, and Newmont alone at 11.6% makes it the most top heavy of the three. GDXJ still leans hard into gold and silver but spreads its risk over more companies, with Alamos Gold at 6.55% and Equinox Gold at 6.25%. That gives you more smaller producers that could plug into shared infrastructure if the Pentagon backed plant reaches commercial production with stable feedstock and firm contracts.
GNR takes a different path. Only 30.1% of the fund is in metals and mining, with large positions in Shell and ExxonMobil. That softens the link to any rare earth revenue but also makes resources exposure broader. It is also the lowest fee at US$40 a year on US$10,000, while GDX and GDXJ cost US$51 and US$52. GDX led GNR by 11.6 percentage points over five years, although that history does not tell you which is better for this policy shift. You decide what you are willing to give up in focus, diversification or fee level to match your own aims.
With 11.6% of GDX riding on Newmont, its next few years matter as much as the fund's. See the earnings forecasts for Newmont.
Fund data as of 12 November 2026. Portfolio holdings as of 12 November 2026.
Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com