-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%

Home Depot Names Richard McPhail CEO as Falling Transactions Reveal a 3% Ticket-Driven Beat

Barchart·11/17/2026 08:34:23
Listen to the news

Home Depot (HD) handed its top job to longtime insider Richard McPhail, naming the CFO as its new chief executive effective November 23. The news came alongside a third-quarter beat on $43.4 billion in sales that failed to excite the market, with investors noticing that customer transactions declined even as average ticket rose 3%.

Ted Decker, who has led the company since 2022 and recently returned from a medical leave that began in August, will step down as CEO but remain board chair, with Ann-Marie Campbell becoming president and COO and Jordan Broggi moving up to CFO.

That fewer shoppers are paying more per visit is the notable but underappreciated detail, signaling that inflation and trade-up activity are doing more work than foot traffic — hardly the cleanest backdrop for a leadership handoff.

Home Depot's Beat by the Numbers

Sales rose 4.9% to $43.4 billion, topping expectations near $42.8 billion, while adjusted EPS of $3.86 edged past the roughly $3.84 consensus in a quarter best described as solid but unspectacular.

Comparable sales — a measure of growth at stores open at least a year — grew 2.2% versus forecasts near 1.8%, and online comps rose about 13%, marking the sixth straight quarter of double-digit digital growth.

Home Depot’s 3% increase in average ticket arrived alongside a decline in customer transactions, meaning the comp beat leaned on pricing and trade-up behavior rather than a surge of shoppers through the doors.

Guidance Refined, Not Raised

Full-year guidance was refined rather than meaningfully raised, with management now expecting about 4.5% total sales growth, the top of the prior range, along with roughly 1.4% comparable growth.

Adjusted EPS is projected to grow about 2%, the midpoint of earlier expectations, a figure that underscores how anemic profit growth remains even as revenue climbs at more than twice that pace.

Nudging sales to the top of the range while holding the EPS outlook at the midpoint suggests that the extra revenue is not translating into faster profit growth.

Why HD Stock Shrugged Off the Beat

HD shares fell as much as 3% in premarket trading, cutting into the stock’s 9% rally over the last month.

That pre-earnings advance effectively priced in a beat, leaving little room for upside once investors saw that the bottom line is growing far more slowly than sales.

To see how day trader Kenny Glick is watching HD for a potential trade setup today, check out this quick clip from our official YouTube channel.

McPhail Bets on the Pro Contractor

McPhail has signaled continuity, emphasizing the Pro contractor strategy he helped build through the SRS Distribution and GMS acquisitions, alongside AI-driven sales tools.

That steadiness reassures investors who might otherwise fear a strategic overhaul, since the incoming CEO helped architect the company's biggest recent bets rather than arriving as an outsider.

The broader reshuffle also keeps the C-suite filled with insiders, with Campbell and Broggi both stepping up as Decker shifts into the chair role.

A Housing Market That Won't Cooperate

However, continuity does not resolve a housing market with mortgage rates above 7% and existing-home sales at their weakest since 2010, conditions that weigh on home-improvement demand.

Those headwinds sit squarely outside management's control regardless of who occupies the corner office, while margin pressure from supply-chain inflation could quickly become the new CEO's first real test.

The Next Catalyst to Watch

Rival Lowe's (LOW)  reports Wednesday, offering investors a direct read on whether Home Depot's share gains are durable or simply a function of higher prices.

A strong Lowe's print would point to industry-wide resilience, while a weak one could sharpen scrutiny of Home Depot's declining transactions and thin profit growth.

Either way, McPhail inherits a company that is beating estimates on the top line — the harder job will be getting more customers, not just bigger receipts, through the door.

This article was created with the support of automated content tools from our partners at Sigma.AI. Together, our financial data and AI solutions help us to deliver more informed market headline analysis to readers faster than ever.   


On the date of publication, Sarah Holzmann did not directly have a position in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.