The stock market’s steep single-day sell-off in early November is being interpreted as a warning of its current vulnerability.
The market, however, doesn’t necessarily move in this manner, and it certainly doesn’t provide discernible warnings.
Investors should continue to focus on what they can control, while recognizing they must also remain prepared for any and all unpredictable possibilities.
Giving credit where it's due, the market's bounced back reasonably well from its horrific Thursday two weeks ago. Specifically, after plunging 4.3% on Nov. 5, the S&P 500 (SNPINDEX:^GSPC) gained back 3.6% by Nov. 11, paring back much of the index's biggest single-day setback since April 2025 (it dropped 2.7% in the two trading days that followed). Investors seem torn right now.
That one-day sell-off is still a stark reminder of just how vulnerable the market is here, seven months since the last major price correction. Only this time, the S&P 500 is even more expensive, interest rates are inching higher again, and inflation has taken another seven months' worth of toll on the economy.
Missed AI’s "Act 1"? Act 2 Could Be 15x Bigger. Most investors think they missed the AI boat because they didn't buy Nvidia in 2005. But according to our analysts, we’re only at the end of "Act 1"—the R&D phase. "Act 2" is the global rollout. Continue »
Image source: Getty Images.
Experienced investors may feel that something is "off" compared to how it was before previous prolonged pullbacks, even if they can't describe exactly what's wrong. Many of these people may also be heading to the sidelines, so to speak, and I understand their concern. The market was 5.1% down from the 52-week high as of Monday’s market close.
I'm not following them off of the playing field, though. I'm staying right where I am, fully invested, even though I know my portfolio might take some lumps soon. Here's why.
Don't misunderstand: I've been scaling back riskier holdings I know I don't want to hold through the next economic growth cycle; my portfolio more or less looks like one you'd expect to see at the end of a bear market and/or the beginning of a bull market.
That's not because of the big tumble from two Thursdays ago, however, or, for that matter, the S&P 500's 6% pullback between its record-high peak made in early October and its early November low. I've been thinking less offensively and more defensively for a few months now, sensing AI mania was about to cool off a bit and allow the broad market to be right-priced.
I'm just not willing to get out of stocks altogether, for a couple of reasons.
First, I don't actually know if the market is due for a more sizable sell-off from here. It might be.
But corrections and bear markets are much like recessions and acquisitions, in that pundits predict far more of them than ever actually materialize. And even when these predictions pan out, their timing isn't meaningfully predictable. It's entirely possible the S&P 500 could end up making another record high before falling under its early-November low.
Since your portfolio should reflect that there's much you just can't predict (and you therefore must maintain balanced preparation for potential unknowns at any given time), my current allocation provides good upside while also limiting my downside risk in this particular market environment.
As much as I'd love to sidestep any sweeping setbacks for the broad market, I also don't want to miss out on any upside. And the fact is, some of the market's biggest daily wins take shape right after sell-offs have run their course, but before most investors trust there's a recovery underway.
Mutual fund company Hartford serves up the data, noting that over the past 20 years, 36% of the market's very biggest single-day wins materialized during just the first two months of a new bull market ... bull markets that last an average of more than 30 months. Moreover, the S&P 500 gains an average of 13.6% in just the first month of a new bull market, and 25.3% over the course of its first three months. Heck, for the past two decades, more than 40% of the stock market's biggest single-day gains unfurled during bear markets.
I'm not saying we're headed into a full-blown bear market marked by a 20% loss. I'm not even predicting that we'll slide into an ordinary correction of just 10%. I'm simply making the point that unless your timing is perfect -- and mine certainly isn't -- attempting to outmaneuver the market's unpredictable ebbs and flows can do more harm than good.
With all that being said, I'd be leery of assuming any meaningful measure of marketwide weakness is inevitable in the foreseeable future at all.
As noted, some of the headlines right now are admittedly alarming. Current circumstances are also a bit unusual, though. With oil prices finally peeling back and interest rates expected to fall -- albeit only slightly -- sometime next year, while the S&P 500's 2027 earnings are projected to grow 11% and push the index nearly 15% higher as a result (according to Goldman Sachs, anyway), it's conceivable we may be able to sidestep the bear market that a growing number of people are worried about. We may even be able to minimize the size of whatever correction we're due.
So, I'm doing what I think most investors should always do. That's focusing on what I can control: finding, buying, and holding high-quality long-term stocks without worrying about predicting the market's unpredictable near-term ebbs and flows. If you can do that, the rest tends to take care of itself.
James Brumley has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Goldman Sachs Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.