A 68-year-old with $500,000 in an S&P 500 index fund owns about $8,425 of Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) without ever picking it. If Elon Musk merges Tesla with SpaceX (NASDAQ: SPCX), that slice could grow to about $11,550, and part of it would be a rocket company she never chose.
Cathie Wood’s ARK Investment Management chose both. It held $2.2 billion of Tesla and SpaceX on Sept. 30, according to the 13F filing ARK sent the Securities and Exchange Commission on Nov. 13. The two Musk companies were ARK’s two largest holdings. Now the boards of both companies are talking about putting them together.
Bloomberg reported on Nov. 12 that merger talks between SpaceX and Tesla are progressing, and on Nov. 14 that a deal could be announced as soon as next month. If it happens, ARK’s two biggest positions would become one stock. So would a small slice of almost every S&P 500 index fund a retiree owns.
What ARK Owned on Sept. 30ARK added to both during the third quarter. It bought 611,881 Tesla shares, lifting its stake 22%, and 2,268,404 SpaceX shares, a 51% increase. GuruFocus reported that ARK bought about $96 million more SpaceX across three of its ETFs in the first week of November.
At Monday’s closing prices of $379.74 for Tesla and $137.36 for SpaceX, the Sept. 30 share counts are worth $2.207 billion: $1.280 billion of Tesla and $927 million of SpaceX. A 13F shows holdings at quarter end, so ARK’s stakes today may differ.
ARK’s Case for the CombinationARK has made the case that the two companies fit together. Its research argues that cash from Tesla’s robotaxi network could pay for SpaceX’s spending on rockets and AI data centers if the two combine, the Motley Fool reported on Nov. 9. ARK’s base case puts Tesla at $4,400 a share in 2031, with robotaxi making up 81% of that value.
Musk called a merger a “good idea” on SpaceX’s third-quarter earnings call and said “there’s a lot of merit to combining the companies.” He said both boards formed special committees of independent directors to weigh it, and that he stays out of those talks as a “conflicted party.”
How a Deal Could WorkAt $2.207 billion, ARK’s combined stake would be about 0.06% of a $3.5 trillion company.
Why a Retiree With an Index Fund Should CareSpaceX listed in June and can’t join the S&P 500 until it has traded for a year. A merger could give it Tesla’s seat sooner. About $16 trillion of passive money tracks the S&P 500, Bloomberg reported, and Reid Noch at TD Securities estimates index funds would buy about $100 billion of stock if the combined company keeps Tesla’s place.
Back to the 68-year-old with $500,000 in an S&P 500 index fund. Tesla was 1.69% of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF on Nov. 13, so about $8,425 of her fund sits in Tesla today. TD’s $100 billion is 0.625% of the $16 trillion that follows the index. Spread evenly, that moves about $3,125 of her $500,000 into the merged company, for roughly $11,550 in one Musk stock. The real figure depends on the deal terms and on how S&P counts shares that trade freely.
“You own all those stocks whether you knowingly intended to or not,” Steve Sosnick, chief strategist at Interactive Brokers, told Bloomberg.
S&P could also hand the seat to another company. In that case, index funds would sell the shares they receive in the merger.
What to WatchFor someone who already owns an S&P 500 fund, the change would happen inside the fund. The decision is whether about $11,550 in one company fits next to any Tesla or SpaceX she owns directly, or an ARK fund, where the two stocks are the largest holdings.