The Zhitong Finance App learned that William Blair downgraded the US rare earth company USA Rare Earth (USAR.US) from “outperforming the market” to a “level with the market” and did not give a target price for the stock. The reason was that a series of recent challenges, including the recent shortage of raw materials is slowing down rare earth magnet production, even though the company “is paving the way for significant upside in the future.” USA Rare Earth shares fell 12.62% on Monday.
William Blair analyst Neal Dingmann said that since the shortage of raw materials will continue to affect the subsidiary Less Common Metals, which in turn affects the Stillwater magnet factory, he has drastically postponed sales and profit margin estimates for USA Rare Earth until 2028.
Dingmann pointed out that the Serra Verde project will ultimately help ease the shortage of raw materials, but 100% of the first phase of the project's production has been promised to SIIE under a 15-year no-negotiable offtake agreement. SIIE is a special purpose carrier supported by the Pentagon and funded by the US government to reduce America's dependence on foreign key mineral sources. However, the raw material support that the Round Top project may provide will take several years to be realized.
In addition, other business sectors are still facing operational challenges when climbing, and the rare earth sector also has news risks. “Therefore, in the short term, we prefer companies with a longer history of material processing,” Dingmann wrote.
The downgrade appears to have affected other key mining stocks as well. Critical Metals (CRML.US) fell 14%, MP Materials (MP.US) fell 6.9%, Rare Earth Americas (REA.US) fell 18.9%, ALB.US (ALB.US) fell 5.7%, Chile Mining Chemicals (SQM.US) fell 4.6%, American Lithium (LAC.US) fell 5.3%, Argentina Lithium (LAR.US) fell 5.4%, and Standard Lithium ( SLI.US) fell 4.4%, Sigma Lithium (SGML.US) fell 12.2%, Atlas Lithium (ATLX.US) fell 5.2%, American Battery Technology (ABAT.US) fell 9.3%, and the US antimony industry (UAMY.US) fell 13.6%.