A RM120 purchase can look remarkably affordable when a checkout screen presents it as three repayments of RM40.
There may be no lengthy application, no plastic card and, in some cases, no interest charge.
The transaction feels less like borrowing and more like selecting a payment preference. Yet the economic reality is simple: the consumer receives a product now and promises to use future income to repay for it later.
That is credit, regardless of the label on the button.
This distinction matters because language shapes behaviour. Terms such as “instalment plan” and “pay in three” can make a financial obligation seem lighter than a conventional loan.
Small repayments may appear harmless when viewed separately, while the total financial commitment receives less attention.
The smoother the checkout journey becomes, the easier it is to forget that convenience today creates a claim on tomorrow’s budget.
Recognising Buy Now, Pay Later or BNPL as credit does not mean declaring it harmful. Used carefully, it can help consumers manage cash flow, spread an essential expense and avoid the interest associated with some products.
It can also support merchants and encourage competition in payments.
These are real benefits.
But useful credit is still credit, and its benefits do not remove the need for suitable safeguards.
The first safeguard is clear disclosure.
Consumers should be able to see, before confirming a purchase, the total amount owed, the number and timing of repayments, any fees or charges, and the consequences of missing a repayment.
This information should be prominent and understandable, not buried in lengthy terms and conditions.
A customer should know exactly how much future income has been committed before tapping “confirm”.
The second safeguard is a proportionate assessment of affordability. A RM120 purchase should not require the same process as a large personal loan.
At the same time, frictionless approval should not become responsibility-free lending.
Providers should use reasonable indicators to identify customers who may struggle, particularly when repayment failures, repeated extensions or rapid borrowing patterns suggest financial stress.
The principle is not to create unnecessary barriers. It is to avoid extending credit where the warning signs are already visible. The third safeguard is visibility of cumulative exposure.
One instalment of RM40 may be manageable.
Five instalments of RM40 across different providers mean RM200 of future income is already committed.
If each provider sees only its own transaction, no one has a complete picture of the consumer’s obligations, and seemingly small purchases can combine into a large problem.
This is why it matters that, under the regulation, BNPL providers are required to start sharing credit information on all their customers.
Once that information flows into the wider credit reporting system, providers and other lenders should take a consumer’s existing BNPL commitments into account before extending further credit, rather than assessing each transaction in isolation. The principle is not to penalise consumers for using BNPL.
It is to ensure that each lending decision reflects the full picture of what a customer already owes.
Critics may argue that regulating BNPL as credit will make a simple product complicated, raise regulatory compliance costs and slow innovation. That risk should be taken seriously.
Poorly designed rules could reduce choice or encourage providers to withdraw services from consumers who use them responsibly.
But the answer is not to pretend that BNPL falls outside the world of credit.
The answer is proportionate regulation, where requirements calibrated to the value, duration, business model and potential harm of the product.
Proportionate treatment could include simpler checks for low-value arrangements and stronger checks as exposure increases.
It could place reasonable limits on late fees, require fair assistance for customers in financial difficulty and establish consistent standards for complaints and collection practices.
It could also improve how providers identify overlapping financial commitments, while ensuring that any use of consumer data is necessary, secure and appropriately governed.
Good regulation need not be the enemy of innovation.
Clear standards can create trust, reward responsible providers and give consumers confidence to use new products.
They can also ensure that competition is based on service and value rather than on who can make a financial obligation feel least like one.
A sustainable BNPL market is not one with no friction at all.
It is one in which the right friction appears at the right moment to prevent foreseeable harm.
The framework should also recognise that financial difficulty is not always evidence of irresponsibility.
Income can fall, medical costs can arise and household expenses can change unexpectedly.
When customers missed repayments, providers should offer clear contact channels, realistic repayment options and temporary support where appropriate.
Collection activity should be firm but fair, and it should not rely on confusing messages or disproportionate pressure.
These protections are not a reward for non-payment.
They are a practical way to prevent a short-term setback from becoming a deeper cycle of debt, while improving the likelihood that legitimate obligations are ultimately repaid.
BNPL’s appeal lies in making purchases feel smaller, simpler and more immediate.
That convenience has genuine value.
But simplicity at checkout should not obscure the obligation that remains after checkout. Consumers deserve flexibility and choice, and responsible providers deserve room to innovate.
Both goals are compatible with a straightforward principle: regulate according to economic substance and in proportion to risk. Buy now, pay later may be a new way to deliver credit. It should not become a way to pretend that credit is something else.
Normasita Sidek serves as credit business director at Suruhanjaya Kredit Pengguna, where she oversees matters relating to the regulation and development of the credit and BNPL sector.