The Zhitong Finance App learned that Federal Reserve Chairman Walsh said on Monday that the rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology may bring productivity jumps and continued growth to the US economy, but it may also cause large-scale unemployment, and even a decline in the stock market and economic slowdown due to lower returns on investment than expected. He stressed that there is still huge uncertainty about the impact of AI on the economy, and the Federal Reserve must prepare for different scenarios and evaluate its potential impact on future monetary policy. It is worth noting that Walsh's speech did not directly address recent monetary policy, nor did it release a new signal about the Fed's future interest rate path. The intraday decline of the three major US stock indices widened. The NASDAQ ended up falling 2.49%, and the S&P 500 index closed down 1.92%.
On the same day, Walsh delivered a speech at a special conference on productivity and employment hosted by the San Francisco Federal Reserve, outlining the three AI development scenarios that Federal Reserve staff are studying. He pointed out that AI may become a new economic and social force, and its impact is different from previous technological revolutions, and in particular, it has unique potential to accelerate knowledge creation and the formation of new ideas.
He used the term “Super Intelligence” (Super Intelligence) in his speech instead of traditional “artificial intelligence.” This statement is consistent with the executive order signed by US President Trump in September this year, which requires federal government agencies to use “superintelligence” and its abbreviation “SI” in official communications.
Under the most optimistic scenario, Walsh believes that the widespread application of AI technology will significantly increase labor productivity, enable enterprises and workers to share the results of economic growth, thereby driving the US real gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate to continue to be higher than the long-term average, while maintaining a state close to full employment.
This scenario is also consistent with Walsh's previous optimistic judgment on AI. He has stated many times that AI-driven productivity increases are expected to promote economic growth while easing inflationary pressure and creating a more favorable long-term development environment for the US economy.
However, Walsh also warned that productivity gains brought about by AI may not translate into widespread employment growth. In the second scenario, enterprises may drastically reduce the demand for manpower through automation technology, leading to the replacement of a large number of jobs. Even if overall economic activity increases, the unemployment rate is likely to rise significantly.
The third scenario is more worthy of financial market alarm: AI technology ultimately fails to meet the high growth expectations placed by investors and companies.
Walsh pointed out that in a situation where companies have invested huge amounts of capital and the stock market has also risen sharply due to the AI investment boom, if the expected returns on related projects begin to decline, stock valuations may fall as a result, leading to a slowdown in economic growth and a significant rise in unemployment.
He said, “After experiencing large-scale capital investment and a rise in the stock market, expected returns may decline, and stock valuations may also fall, leading to a slowdown in the economy and a more significant rise in unemployment.”
Walsh added that under such circumstances, the economy will eventually recover, but the productivity increase previously anticipated may not be realized.
In recent years, the development prospects of AI technology have driven technology stock valuations to continue to rise, and has also prompted enterprises to raise capital through equity and debt financing to support research and development of data centers, computing power infrastructure and related technologies. The third scenario proposed by Walsh highlights the market's potential concerns about AI return on investment and valuation sustainability.
However, he stressed that the above three scenarios are not the Federal Reserve's official predictions of future economic trends, but rather help policymakers understand the different consequences that technological change may bring. “Our job is to be prepared for whatever may happen in the future.” Walsh said that the role of the Federal Reserve on this issue is neither an advocate nor an opponent; rather, it is necessary to recognize that the widespread application of new technology will have a significant impact on the economy and may have an important impact on future monetary policy.
He pointed out that the most critical issue at present is the extent, scope, and timing of AI's impact on the economy.
In fact, the impact of the AI boom on the economy is already beginning to be felt, but the short-term results may differ from long-term expectations. Walsh previously believed that AI-driven productivity growth could drive economic expansion while curbing inflation. However, at an event hosted by the International Monetary Fund in Bangkok in October this year, he acknowledged that the prices of materials and other inputs required for AI infrastructure construction have risen sharply, putting pressure on overall inflation.
He pointed out at the time that the AI investment boom clearly first stimulated economic demand, and that its positive impact on the supply side would take longer to be reflected.
According to the latest data, labor productivity in the US increased by 3.6% on an annualized basis in the third quarter, the fastest growth rate in a year. However, economists believe that AI's direct contribution to productivity improvement is still relatively limited.
This means that although AI is expected to improve economic efficiency over the long term, before large-scale technology investment is transformed into actual productivity growth, related capital expenditure may also drive up resource demand and price levels, making monetary policy formulation face a more complicated situation.
In order to thoroughly study these issues, after becoming Chairman of the Federal Reserve in June of this year, Walsh announced the establishment of five working groups led by external experts to study topics such as productivity and employment, the Federal Reserve's communication methods, data dependency, balance sheet policy, and the inflation framework.
Among them, the working group responsible for studying the impact of AI on productivity and employment was led by Marc Andreessen (Marc Andreessen), a well-known venture capitalist and co-founder of Andreessen Horowitz. Members also include Microsoft (MSFT.US) Xbox CEO Asha Sharma, and Stanford University scholar Charles Jones.
Monday's conference brought together tech executives, economists, academics, and Federal Reserve officials to discuss the potential impact of AI on US economic growth, labor markets, and productivity. Participants included Federal Reserve Governor Cook, Stanford University economist Nick Bloom, and Nikesh Arora, Chairman and CEO of cybersecurity company Palo Alto Networks (PANW.US).
Some participants believed that America's speed advantage in applying new technology may help its economic growth continue to lead other countries. However, some experts worry that excessive reliance on AI tools may reduce students' ability to learn independently.
Walsh said earlier that these working groups are expected to put forward policy proposals before the end of this year, and then submit them to the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), which is responsible for monetary policy decisions.
He said that AI is driving the economy into a new stage of development, but it is still uncertain whether it will eventually bring stronger growth, a more serious impact on employment, or whether it will be a round of market adjustments after falling short of investment expectations. For the Federal Reserve, how to identify the real impact of this technological change on economic growth, employment, and inflation will be an important challenge in formulating monetary policy in the future.