American Express has delivered strong share price gains over the past three years, yet the current valuation still comes down to a simple question for investors: Is today’s price supported by the returns the business earns on the capital it puts to work?
The issue now is whether the returns American Express earns on its capital are strong enough and durable enough to make today’s share price look sensible on that basis.
If you are evaluating American Express by the returns it generates on each dollar of capital, it may be useful to compare that perspective with other stocks screened on 34 high quality undervalued stocks
The Excess Returns model starts from what American Express earns on shareholder capital, not just from its cash flows. Book Value sits at $53.35 per share and Stable EPS at $21.49 per share, implying that the business is expected to generate sizeable profits on a relatively modest equity base.
Average Return on Equity of 36.16% against a Cost of Equity of $4.92 per share leaves an estimated Excess Return of $16.57 per share, which is what this approach is really pricing. Stable Book Value is projected at $59.42 per share, so the framework assumes American Express keeps reinvesting at healthy rates rather than coasting on its existing card portfolio. Despite the recent launch of ChatGPT Wallet with OpenAI potentially pulling more spending onto the American Express network, the Excess Returns model still places the estimated intrinsic value meaningfully above the current share price of $320.60. Find out what American Express could be worth using our Excess Returns estimate.
Simply Wall St Narratives take that valuation puzzle for American Express and turn it into a set of clear, testable "if this, then that" stories that link the share price to specific paths for growth, margins and earnings. Rather than resting on a single multiple or model output, each narrative lays out the assumptions behind its view of fair value so you can line those expectations up against American Express' actual results as they come through.
Bulls and bears looking at American Express are working off the same trust story but drawing very different conclusions about what the price already reflects.
Bull case: 28% undervalued
According to John_Eric, an investor in the Simply Wall St Community, the long history of American Express is the key to the upside story.
"American Express has spent 176 years selling one product under a dozen different names, trust, and its operating results remain excellent while Berkshire Hathaway has kept its enormous stake untouched..."
Discover why this Narrative puts American Express at 28% undervalued.
Bear case: 7% overvalued
andre_santos, a Simply Wall St Community investor who wrote the Narrative, argues that the valuation already bakes in a lot of good news.
"Please remember that the fair value estimate is just a number and, probably, a very wrong number, however, overall, American Express seems to be overvalued..."
Explore why this Narrative puts American Express at 7% overvalued.
Valuation tells you what the market is willing to pay for American Express today, but the people deciding where cash is spent and how they are rewarded can shape what happens next. See who runs American Express and how they are paid.
Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com