At the 24% bracket, a $600,000 portfolio split evenly across six blue-chip dividend payers generates $26,360 a year. Held in a taxable account, about $4,460 of that goes to the IRS. Inside a Roth IRA, qualified distributions are excluded from gross income under 26 U.S.C. § 408A(d)(1), so the account keeps the full amount.
Six Dividend Stocks, $100,000 EachEvery position gets $100,000. The yields below are trailing 12-month figures, and together they give the portfolio a combined yield of 4.39%.
Stock Yield Annual Income Tax Character Realty Income (NYSE:O) 5.64% $5,640 Ordinary Verizon (NYSE:VZ) 6.22% $6,220 Qualified Altria (NYSE:MO) 5.58% $5,580 Qualified AbbVie (NYSE:ABBV) 2.42% $2,420 Qualified Chevron (NYSE:CVX) 3.13% $3,130 Qualified Duke Energy (NYSE:DUK) 3.37% $3,370 QualifiedRealty Income is the only holding taxed at the full 24% rate, which costs $1,354 a year on that position alone. The other five generate qualified dividends. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1(h)(11), those are taxed like capital gains, generally at the 15% rate in § 1(h)(1)(C).
Metric Roth IRA Taxable Account Gross income $26,360 $26,360 Federal tax $0 $4,460 Net income $26,360 $21,900 10-year Roth advantage (no growth) $44,620Dividends that fail the qualified holding-period test in § 1(h)(11)(B)(iii) face ordinary income tax rates. If that happened to the whole portfolio, the 24% bill would rise to $6,326.
Bracket Multiplier Raises the StakesThe portfolio and its gross income stay the same. What changes is the bracket. Top-bracket taxpayers pay 20% on qualified dividends under § 1(h)(1)(D), which is why the gap jumps at 37%. These figures leave out state tax and the net investment income tax.
Bracket Taxable Net Income The Yearly Roth Advantage 22% $22,010 $4,350 24% $21,900 $4,460 32% $21,450 $4,910 37% $20,130 $6,230 Compounding Turns $4,460 Into $132,860The annual gap is only the starting point. Say you reinvest the tax you avoid each year at a conservative 4%, which is below the 10-year Treasury yield of 4.90% on Nov. 4. At the 24% bracket, the Roth advantage then grows to about $53,570 after 10 years and $132,860 after 20. These numbers assume no dividend growth and no price gains. They show what holding these six stocks outside a Roth costs you over time (if you’re still in the low-tax years between your last paycheck and your first RMD, that’s the cheapest window to move them, something we sized up in a free Roth conversion guide).
What to Check Before Your Next Filing