3 Profitable Small Cap Stocks With ROE Over 23%

Big tech is pouring cash into AI infrastructure and pulling back on share buybacks, which leaves many popular stocks looking fully crowded. That shift creates room for smaller, profitable businesses that are not soaking up headlines but are quietly building real earning power. This article walks through three underfollowed high quality small caps from our screener and explains how they may offer fresher ideas compared with the usual mega cap picks.

The picks below are just a sample of what surfaced, and the full screen pulled out 16 more underfollowed companies with equally compelling stories that are not covered in this article.

If you want to move first rather than wait for the upgrade note, head straight into the High-Quality Undiscovered Gems screener to identify, compare, and analyze potential high conviction ideas hiding outside the usual watchlists.

IDT (IDT)

IDT blends legacy communications with a growing fintech and retail-technology arm, and that mix is exactly what this screener looks for. The most interesting piece for High-Quality Undiscovered Gems investors sits inside its National Retail Solutions platform, which is where the following quote really matters.

IDT runs several segments, from Traditional Communications on about $865 million of revenue to fintech services on roughly $176 million and its National Retail Solutions retail-tech platform on about $159 million, with Net2phone adding around $97 million. This gives this US$2 billion small cap multiple levers inside one group.

"The advertising business finally has a number attached to it. NRS’s ad and data revenue ... has grown 49% to $10 million, “bolstered by a recent acquisition.”"

What really moves the needle from here depends on how one quiet shift in this retail-tech engine plays out against expectations.

That quiet shift is exactly what the full narrative for IDT unpacks, highlighting how NRS’s ad engine, capital allocation, and risk trade off could be decoupling from legacy communications.

Exzeo Group (XZO)

Exzeo Group fits directly into the High-Quality Undiscovered Gems theme through its Exzeo Platform, which gives property and casualty insurers a ready-made tech and operations stack instead of requiring them to patch together legacy systems and manual workflows.

Exzeo Group runs its Insurance-as-a-Service tools across a single reported line, Insurance - Property & Casualty. This line produced about $230 million of revenue in the United States, and the stock is valued at roughly $1.6 billion.

"Structural digitization across the insurance industry is driving carriers to retire legacy systems and adopt integrated cloud platforms like Exzeo, which is expected to support revenue growth as managed premium scales from the current 1.2 billion base."

The central question for Exzeo Group is how long its high margin model can absorb heavier investment in the platform before investors begin to question the payoff.

That trade off is exactly where the story gets interesting, and the full narrative for Exzeo Group shows how Exzeo Group’s model could mask both pressure points and accelerating upside.

HCI Group (HCI)

HCI Group mixes a large homeowners insurance book with a quieter insurtech engine in its Exzeo platform. This fits neatly with the High-Quality Undiscovered Gems theme of small caps using strong fundamentals and under-recognized software to build more scalable earnings power.

HCI Group generates most of its revenue from Insurance Operations on about $853 million. Exzeo contributes roughly $230 million, Reciprocal Exchange Operations around $93 million, and Real Estate close to $17 million. The business is valued at about $2.5 billion.

"The public valuation of Exzeo around US$1.5 billion and management’s estimate that pro forma book value per share would exceed US$150 if the fair value of Exzeo and the real estate portfolio were recognized point to a gap between reported and economic equity that could narrow through future monetization events and help support book value and return on equity."

The real swing factor is how a shift in where future profits come from ends up feeding into margins and investor attention.

That shift in earnings mix is exactly what the full narrative for HCI Group unpacks, showing where HCI Group’s insurance engine could be masking accelerating value in Exzeo.

Curious About Your Next Alternative?

Fresh ideas do not stay quiet for long. Breakout moves, new momentum and under the radar for now insights tend to get caught quickly. Scan these while it matters and get in early.

• Spot cash rich, beaten down opportunities before they start flying by running your eye over the 35 high quality undervalued stocks curated for balance sheet strength and real cash generation.
• Track structural shifts in energy and infrastructure with the 16 nuclear energy infrastructure stocks built to highlight potential long run operators in power, grids and supporting hardware.
• Target growing automation tailwinds through the 91 robotics and automation stocks and see which specialist manufacturers and software providers are building staying power while attention is still limited.

Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com