-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%

Canada's “legal visit” bill blocked by tech giants: Meta, Apple, Alphabet gather in the Senate to try to rewrite the bill

智通财经·11/16/2026 12:41:14
语音播报

The Zhitong Finance App learned that Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney's administration is being strongly opposed by large technology companies due to a security legislation. The bill would require businesses to keep user data and surrender it when required by law enforcement.

Lobbyists and executives of Meta (META.US), Apple (AAPL.US), and Alphabet (GOOGL.US) are making the final push in Ottawa to push for amendments before the bill is passed. On Monday, the heads of Meta, Signal Messenger, and Tailscale will bring this wrestle to a key Senate committee hearing, which will determine the final shape of the bill.

Bill C-22, the so-called “lawful access” legislation, aims to allow Canadian intelligence agencies and police to compel electronic service providers to retain and surrender certain metadata. The government insisted that these measures only brought Canada in line with its “Five Eyes Alliance” and G7 allies.

Tech companies, privacy advocates, and US lawmakers countered that the bill went far beyond the framework adopted by similar countries in Canada, and warned that it would threaten platform security and user privacy. Meta claims the law would actually expropriate its platform as an “extension of the government's surveillance machine.”

Rachel Curren, head of public policy at Meta Canada, said in an interview: “There is a real possibility that the security and privacy of Canadian users of these systems will be truly compromised.”

For the Carney administration, the battle could curb investment in technology, heighten tension with the US government, and push privacy-focused platforms out of the Canadian market. Signal has threatened to withdraw from Canada if the bill passes in its current version. Swiss tech company Proton said it will reconsider its expansion plans in Canada.

One rule that critics object to is that the rule would allow the government to force electronic service providers to keep certain user metadata for up to six months in order to disclose it to law enforcement officials if needed.

The proposed law may also force some businesses to unlock encrypted data, but only if those companies have constructed their own encryption and have the information needed to unlock it. Earlier this year, lawmakers amended the bill to make it clear that companies must also not be forced to introduce “systemic bugs” into their software.

These protections are meant to ease concerns from companies such as Signal and Meta (which owns WhatsApp) that the bill targets end-to-end encryption. This type of encryption ensures that only the sender and receiver can read the message, meaning the company cannot decrypt it.

Even so, privacy advocates and tech leaders believe that the bill still gives the government broad powers to order companies to build “technical capabilities” to intercept communications and hand over data.

Tech companies have long warned that they can't just open a “back door” for law enforcement without compromising the safety of all users. Curran said that any order that would make the Meta system more vulnerable is a “red line” for the company, and its industry peers are likely to be the same.

“This could put Canada in a situation where eventually there will be some kind of standoff between service providers and the government, which is not good for Canadians,” she said.

A global precedent

The UK and Apple got into a similar dispute last year, when the British government ordered the company to bypass its encryption technology to protect user data for cloud services. Apple challenged the order and removed advanced data protection features for UK users. The case is still pending in court.

“In the hypothetical future, if we were faced with a similar order, we would have to consider these options,” said Curran.

Public Safety Minister Gary Ananda Sangari said the bill has been amended to ease concerns raised by Apple in the UK about the possible impact on encryption. He accuses some critics, including big tech companies, of spreading false information about the bill.

Minister Spokesman Simon Lafourtoun said in a statement: “Bill C-22 does not authorize indiscriminate surveillance, nor does it allow or force companies to introduce systemic breaches or so-called 'back doors'. Any statement to the contrary is false.”

Apple said in a statement that it appreciates the Canadian government's efforts to improve the bill, but the current version will still weaken the company's ability to provide privacy and security features (including encryption), “especially at a time when AI and other evolving technologies provide hackers with new tools to take advantage of cybersecurity weaknesses.”

US lawmakers have also raised objections. In May, Republican Rep. Jim Jordan and Brian Master warned in a letter to Ananda Sangari that the bill would “pose a significant cross-border risk to Americans' security and data privacy.”

The Canadian Senate Committee is the last legislative hurdle before the bill is likely to go into effect. This appointed parliament rarely directly vetoes bills, but often secures amendments, leaving a final window of lobbying for tech giants and privacy advocates.