3 Insurance Stocks Worth Watching As Bond Income Comes Back Into Focus

Bond markets are back in the spotlight, with higher government yields, rising borrowing costs and renewed inflation worries reshaping where investors look for returns and resilience. That shift is creating fresh risks for some stocks and fresh potential for others that are more closely tied to bond income. This article unpacks the recent news shock and walks through three insurers that are especially exposed to these cross currents right now.

The insurers highlighted below are just a starting sample, and the full screen surfaced 13 more global property & casualty and life companies with equally compelling bond income stories that are not covered here. If you want to go straight to the source and identify, compare and analyze those insurers by size, yield sensitivity and balance sheet strength, head into the Global Property & Casualty Insurers and Life Insurers with Large Bond Portfolios screener.

Employers Holdings (EIG)

Overview: Employers Holdings is a US workers’ compensation insurer focused on small businesses in lower risk industries. This naturally ties it to a large bond portfolio used to back long dated policy reserves and generate investment income. It distributes coverage through a mix of independent agents, trade groups and direct channels. Investors are therefore really looking at a balance sheet driven insurer that turns underwriting discipline and bond yields into overall returns.

Operations: Employers Holdings generates all of its US$837.6 million in revenue from Insurance Operations in the United States.

Market Cap: US$882 million

Rising global bond yields put Employers Holdings in focus because its workers’ comp book is backed by a sizable fixed income portfolio where new money yields have recently been reported north of 5%. Each maturing bond can potentially be recycled into higher income over time even as equity markets feel pressure from higher discount rates. At the same time, earnings and margins have been under strain and the dividend has not been fully covered by recent profits, so it is important to weigh that income potential against underwriting pressure, regulatory risk in key states such as California and a funding structure that relies on external capital rather than deposits. Strong reserve quality, active buybacks and fresh board level risk oversight add further layers to the story that may be missed if you only look at headline revenue trends.

Employers Holdings appears to be a bond income story that investors may not have fully pieced together yet, with higher new money yields, reserve quality and buybacks all pulling in different directions. Get the full picture in the 2 key rewards and 2 important warning signs (1 is major!)

Fidelity National Financial (FNF)

Overview: Fidelity National Financial is a US based title insurer and real estate services company that also offers annuities, life insurance and pension risk transfer products, which together create a sizeable bond backed balance sheet sensitive to interest rates. Its mix of title insurance, escrow, technology and mortgage services, plus the F&G annuities and life segment, gives investors exposure to both real estate transaction volumes and long dated insurance liabilities funded by investment portfolios.

Operations: Fidelity National Financial generates most of its US$15.4b in revenue from its Title segment at US$9.0b and F&G Annuities & Life at US$6.1b, with the remainder from Corporate and Other activities, all in the United States.

Market Cap: US$12.5b

Investors looking at insurers with large bond portfolios may find Fidelity National Financial interesting because it pairs a substantial investment book with cash flows from both title insurance and the F&G annuities and life business. Rising bond yields can increase investment income over time as assets are reinvested. This supports a 4.52% dividend and ongoing buybacks. At the same time, the company is still working through margin pressure, a recent year of earnings decline and funding that leans on external borrowing rather than deposits. In addition, regulatory experiments around alternative title models and the push to a more fee based, capital light structure highlight how the balance between bond income potential and earnings volatility can be important for investors.

Fidelity National Financial’s bond income story is easy to overlook next to real estate headlines. Yet its mix of title cash flows and long dated liabilities could be crucial. Get the full context in the 4 key rewards and 2 important warning signs

Kingstone Companies (KINS)

Overview: Kingstone Companies is a US based property and casualty insurer that focuses on personal lines such as homeowners, condos, renters and umbrella policies. This naturally ties its claims reserves to a bond heavy investment portfolio that can benefit from higher bond yields over time. It also writes some commercial auto, for hire vehicle and canine liability cover, giving investors exposure to a specialist regional insurer that leans on fixed income income rather than high risk investments.

Operations: Kingstone Companies generates all of its US$237.7 million in revenue from Property and Casualty Insurance in the United States.

Market Cap: US$284.5 million

Kingstone Companies may appeal to investors who want a smaller insurer whose earnings are closely tied to a largely fixed income portfolio at a time when higher government bond yields are back in focus. Management reports that more than 95% of the portfolio sits in bonds and other income focused securities, return on equity (ROE) has been measured at 27.3% and the stock trades on a low price to earnings (P/E) multiple with what looks like a large discount to estimated fair value. The flip side is a funding mix that leans on external borrowings and a balance sheet that feels every move in rates and credit spreads. How that trade off plays out between higher investment income and market volatility is where the opportunity and risk sit for investors who go deeper than the headline numbers.

Kingstone Companies looks like an overlooked bond income and ROE story, yet the low P/E and apparent discount hint that something else may be at work. See how the analysis report for Kingstone Companies could change your view.

Seeking Alternatives Beyond Bond-Heavy Insurers

Fresh ideas move first when momentum starts to build. Some stocks are already approaching breakout levels while others are dropping into value territory under the radar for now, act now.

• Spot companies quietly building momentum before the crowd notices by scanning the 19 high quality undiscovered gems and see which stories still look mispriced while it matters.
• Target resilient balance sheets so sharp sell offs do not catch you off guard by running the 74 resilient stocks with low risk scores and focusing on stocks with measured downside risk.
• Ride structural shifts in energy demand instead of chasing yesterday’s winners by reviewing the 91 nuclear energy infrastructure stocks and seeing which infrastructure stocks may be setting up for the next leg.

This article by Simply Wall St is general in nature. We provide commentary based on historical data and analyst forecasts only using an unbiased methodology and our articles are not intended to be financial advice. It does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and does not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. We aim to bring you long-term focused analysis driven by fundamental data. Note that our analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material. Simply Wall St has no position in any stocks mentioned.

Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com